- Home
- How-to guides
- How to choose a dog trainer
Choosing a trainer
How to choose a dog trainer
Anyone can call themselves a dog trainer; the AKC describes the field as unregulated. That puts the checking on you, and it is quicker than it sounds. This page covers what to decide before you call, how to read a trainer's methods and letters, what a good first session looks like, and the signs that should send you elsewhere. Our board-and-train guides cover the extra questions for a stay away from home.
Before you start
Before you start, write the goal down, because the goal decides which kind of trainer you need
AVSAB's guide to choosing a trainer begins with goals and gives examples: puppy socialization, manners and life skills, sports, service work and behavior concerns. Each points to a different professional. A puppy needs careful early lessons; a dog that drags you along Stacy Boulevard needs leash skills; a dog that growls at visitors is a behavior case. AVSAB adds that fear, anxiety or aggression call for a veterinarian with advanced behavior knowledge, a board-certified veterinary behaviorist or a credentialed behavior consultant.
Then choose the format. The AKC notes that a group class brings socialization and practice around distraction, while private lessons, at a training school, at home or out in the world, suit dogs that are overstimulated or anxious around other dogs. Dogtown offers structured programs such as Bright Beginnings and Calm & Connected over 4, 6 or 8 weeks, and private sessions from $94 for one specific problem; the assessment decides which suits your dog. One clear sentence about the goal tells you what to ask for.
- General manners and life skills: a structured program or class
- One problem at home or on walks: private sessions
- Fear, anxiety or aggression: a veterinary or credentialed behavior professional involved
- A title such as the AKC Canine Good Citizen: a trainer who prepares dogs for that test
Method and credentials
Check the method before the credentials, because a certificate does not decide what goes on your dog's neck
AVSAB calls positive reinforcement highly effective, humane and ethical, and calls training that relies on force, intimidation or pain unnecessary and unethical, warning that aversive methods can make problem behaviors worse. The research agrees on welfare. A 2020 PLOS ONE study of 92 companion dogs found that those from schools using high proportions of aversive methods showed more stress-related behaviors, larger rises in cortisol after training and more pessimistic responses in a cognitive test than dogs from reward-based schools.
Credentials come second. The AKC notes that certification is optional for trainers, and AVSAB lists the Karen Pryor Academy, Jean Donaldson's Academy for Dog Trainers, the Victoria Stillwell Academy, the Pet Professional Guild, the International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants and Fear Free as backgrounds that make reward-based methods more likely, while cautioning that letters alone do not settle quality. Look up any credential with the body that issued it. Dogtown's training is led by Gabriella Pope, our Director of Training & Canine Behaviorist, and is fear- and force-free in every program.
- Rewards you can see: treats, toys, praise, a clicker or a marker word
- Plain equipment: a flat collar or harness and an ordinary leash
- Any credential confirmed in the issuing body's directory
- Lessons that explain how dogs learn, not only which cue to say
The steps
Find, read, ask, watch and try: six steps to a trainer you can trust
The AKC's checklist is practical: collect recommendations, then do your own research anyway; ask about methods, philosophy, education and references; and try to watch a class, keeping an eye on the dogs and the owners as much as on the trainer. It also describes the lessons you should expect. They cover dog behavior, communication and how dogs learn, because a great trainer's job is to teach you to train your dog.
A good first session is mostly questions. Expect the trainer to ask about history, health, routine and the exact moments the problem appears, to watch your dog before handling it, to try one small exercise and to send you home with short homework. If the session is all demonstration and no explanation, or your dog is handled roughly, you have learned what you needed to know. From Rockport, Essex or Manchester-by-the-Sea, count the drive to each trainer as part of the cost, since sessions repeat.
- 01
Write the goal in one sentence, with what your dog does, where it happens and when it started.
- 02
Gather two or three names from people you trust and from directories such as the CCPDT's and the AKC's list of approved Canine Good Citizen evaluators.
- 03
Read each website and watch its videos for method words, equipment and how relaxed the dogs look.
- 04
Ask each trainer about methods and equipment, education and credentials, and references from former students.
- 05
Watch a class or a session if you can, keeping an eye on the dogs and owners as much as the trainer.
- 06
Book one session, bring your notes, and judge it by whether the homework is clear, short and still working a week later.
Red flags
Walk away from harsh handling, dominance talk and a trainer who will not let you watch
AVSAB's red-flag column is specific: prong or shock collars; pushing, pulling, poking or hitting; leash jerks; rolling a dog onto its back; twisting ears or lips; rattle cans and water spray bottles; talk of boss, alpha, pack leader or dominance; a harsh voice, yelling or stomping; and a style that shuts down normal dog behavior and demands control. The green column is the mirror image: rewards, an upbeat voice, friendly body language, and a plan that prevents unwanted behavior while teaching a replacement.
Two more flags follow from the AKC's advice. A trainer who will not explain the method, or will not let you watch a class, leaves you unable to do the checking it recommends. Be wary as well of any promise of results by a date, because dogs learn at their own pace and the practice at home decides the outcome. AVSAB's last step applies in any session: if your dog looks stressed or you do not feel heard, speak up, ask for other options or leave.
- Prong, choke or shock collars, leash jerks or rolling a dog over
- Boss, alpha, pack leader or dominance language
- Yelling, stomping or a harsh tone, with dogs or with owners
- No observing allowed and no plain answer on methods
- A fixed promise of results by a set date
When to call us
Call us when you want a force-free plan built around your dog's goal
Training at Dogtown starts with the training form, and we reply within one hour on business days. Next comes a short assessment with Gabriella Pope, who chooses the program and the level, and the plan and its cost are confirmed after it. Sessions start from $94. Programs include Tiny Tails Puppy School for pups 8 to 16 weeks, React Less, Relax More over 8 weeks and 16 sessions, and AKC S.T.A.R. Puppy and Canine Good Citizen preparation.
Gabby's published background is a B.S. in Biochemistry, ten-plus years with behaviorally complex dogs, work with Autistic youth and fostering dogs through Cape Ann Animal Aid. If you are comparing trainers on the North Shore, put every question on this page to us as well, at 210 Eastern Ave in Gloucester or on the form. If your dog also needs structured days while you work, every Dogtown Academy day includes a training session with our trainer.
At Dogtown
Force-free training at Dogtown
Programs from puppy school to behavior modification, private sessions from $94, and Academy days with a training session built in.
Asked and answered
Questions people ask about this
Short, complete answers you can act on today. More in the full FAQ.
Is a group class or private training better for my dog?
Do dog trainers need a license in Massachusetts?
What happens in a first training session?
Is balanced training the same as force-free training?
How quickly can I start training at Dogtown?
More questions? Read the full FAQ
Sources
- AVSAB: How to Choose a Trainer
- AKC: how to find and choose a dog trainer
- Vieira de Castro et al., PLOS ONE (2020): does training method matter?
Rules and dates change. We re-check every beach, licensing and ordinance page each spring and fall; the source above is the current word.
Keep reading
Next step
Ask how we train, then decide.
Send the training form with your dog's goal and your questions about method. We reply within one hour on business days and arrange a short assessment with Gabriella Pope.
- 01Free evaluationWeekdays 6:30 – 9:30 AM
- 02Book a dayOnline, in the app or by phone
- 03Play, rest, repeatReport card at pick-up