- Home
- Board and train
- Board and train vs online dog training
Screen or hands-on
Board and train vs online dog training
Online training covers a wide range, from a free app of trick videos to a paid course in which an instructor reviews clips of you and your dog. None of it is wrong. The question is which parts of your dog's problem a screen can actually reach.
Side by side
Online training teaches you first; board and train trains the dog first and then teaches you
In online training you are the trainer from day one. A course explains the method, you try it with your dog, and depending on the format someone may comment on your attempt. The AKC describes three common levels of online class: auditing the material, joining the class forum, or taking a working spot in which you submit video for an instructor's feedback. Only the last lets anyone see your timing, and even then the feedback arrives after the moment has passed.
Board and train starts with the dog in experienced hands. During a Foundation or Advanced stay at 210 Eastern Ave, Gabriella Pope's team trains your dog daily, adjusts on the spot when it struggles, and uses steady dogs and people in the building as controlled distractions. You read a daily update, then learn the cues in person at the go-home lesson, or across two coaching lessons in Advanced.
| Board and train | Online training | |
|---|---|---|
| Who handles the dog while it learns | Our trainers, every day | You |
| Feedback on your handling | In person, at 1 or 2 lessons | None, or on video you submit |
| Real dogs and people as distractions | Set up in the building | Whatever you can arrange |
| Schedule | One or two fixed weeks | Any time, at your own pace |
| Finishing | Built into the stay | Up to you |
| At Dogtown | Quoted after an assessment | No online program published |
| Best for | Dogs that need a trainer's hands and set-ups | Owners learning concepts with an easygoing dog |
What online does well
Online formats are good at concepts, home routines and owners who learn by watching and replaying
A good course explains why a marker works, how to shape a behavior in small steps and how to arrange a room so the dog cannot rehearse the wrong habit, and you can replay each lesson as often as you like. The AKC points out that online classes let you assess your own training skills separately from the training of the dog, and let owners take part on their own schedule, which suits shift workers and households that cannot reach a weekly class.
Online work also happens where the problem lives. An AKC article on virtual training reported that students could practice in the very environment where the behaviors were happening. House routines, crate games, tricks, enrichment and the basics with a calm puppy or a willing adult are well within reach of a motivated owner with a phone, a mat and a treat pouch.
- Concepts: markers, shaping, management
- Home routines: crate, mat, mealtimes, greetings at your own door
- Tricks and enrichment for a willing dog
- Owners who will film themselves and watch it back
Where hands-on wins
Hands-on training wins when timing, distance and real distractions decide the outcome
Some skills hinge on split-second timing that a beginner rarely has and a screen cannot correct live, such as marking a glance away from another dog or rewarding a recall before the dog changes its mind. Others need set-ups most homes cannot stage, like a calm dog walking past at a chosen distance or a stranger who follows a script. In our building those are ordinary, and a trainer reading the dog in the room can lower the difficulty the moment it struggles.
Then there is finishing. In a 2019 Dogs Trust pilot in northern England, none of the 32 owners who began a free online introductory course completed it, while 29 of the 51 who started the matching face-to-face classes did. It was a small study of free courses in low-income areas, and its authors point to barriers beyond cost, but it is a fair warning that a course only works if you reach the end. A stay finishes the first part for you.
Choosing a course
If you use an online course before or after a stay, check its method and its feedback first
Online and hands-on training can work together. Some families learn marker basics from a course before a stay, so the go-home lesson lands on a prepared handler; others use one afterward to keep practice fresh. Dogtown does not publish an online or video-call program, so ask on the training form if remote follow-up matters to you. Whatever course you choose should teach the same way your dog was taught.
Method is the first filter. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior's 2021 position statement recommends reward-based methods for all dog training, so a course that sells or recommends prong, choke or shock collars is teaching something your dog's stay will not. Feedback is the second filter, because watching is not doing, and access is the third: the AKC notes that online classes often set an end date for viewing the material.
- 01
Read the course's method page and look for reward-based training
- 02
Check whether any equipment is sold or required
- 03
Find out whether an instructor reviews video of you
- 04
Check how long you keep access to the material
- 05
Start with one skill and finish it before buying more
On Cape Ann
On Cape Ann, the places a screen cannot reach are the ones your dog will need most
A course can teach a recall in a living room. It cannot put your dog on Good Harbor on an even-numbered October morning, when Gloucester allows dogs off leash from October 1 to March 31 at the time of writing, with gulls lifting and another dog coming down the sand. Nor can it walk your dog through downtown Gloucester on a July afternoon. Those tests need a solid skill and a plan for stepping up to them, one difficulty at a time.
If you choose the hands-on route, the first steps are local and short: the training form, a reply within the hour on business days, the assessment with Gabriella Pope, and the free evaluation on a weekday morning between 6:30 and 9:30. Families in Rockport, Gloucester, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea can add the Pup Van to the stay for $10 each way.
- Off-leash practice: follow the city's beach calendar
- Summer: busy sidewalks, so neutrality matters most
- Pup Van: four Cape Ann towns, $10 each way
At Dogtown
Hands-on training at Dogtown
Private sessions and board and train both start with a short assessment in Gloucester.
Pick-up & drop-off
The Pup Van comes to you.
Pup Van pick-up and drop-off is available for $10 each way in the Rockport, Gloucester, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea area. Not in the area? Ask us for pricing.
- Rockport
- Gloucester
- Essex
- Manchester-by-the-Sea
Asked and answered
Questions people ask about this
Short, complete answers you can act on today. More in the full FAQ.
Can an app fix leash pulling?
Do you offer online or video sessions?
Is online training enough for a puppy?
Can I use an online course after board and train?
Which is better for a reactive dog?
More questions? Read the full FAQ
Sources
- AKC: online training, a new resource for dog owners
- AKC: making the most of virtual dog training
- Harris et al. 2019, Animals: access to dog training classes, online and face to face
- AVSAB position statement on humane dog training, 2021
- City of Gloucester: beaches
Rules and dates change. We re-check every beach, licensing and ordinance page each spring and fall; the source above is the current word.
Keep reading
Next step
When a screen is not enough.
Tell us what you have tried online and where it stalled. The training team answers within the hour on business days.
- 01Free evaluationWeekdays 6:30 – 9:30 AM
- 02Book a dayOnline, in the app or by phone
- 03Play, rest, repeatReport card at pick-up
