1. Home
  2. Board and train
  3. Will my dog bond with the trainer instead of me?

Bonds, not swaps

Will my dog bond with the trainer instead of me?

It is a fair worry. You are paying someone else to spend one or two weeks teaching your dog, and you have seen how dogs light up for people who feed and play with them. Here is what research says about new bonds, what a stay does to the one you have, and how the reunion and the handover are set up.

Dogtown staff member holding a smiling husky

New bonds

Dogs form new bonds quickly, so a trainer who feeds and plays with yours will be liked

A 2001 study in the Journal of Comparative Psychology tested how fast adult dogs attach. Gácsi and colleagues observed 60 shelter dogs in an adapted version of the Strange Situation Test; 40 of them had first been handled three times for ten minutes. Those dogs sought more contact with their handler, paid less attention to a stranger and waited less by the door while the handler was in the room. The authors concluded the response met their criteria for attachment, formed in very little time.

Two caveats matter. Shelter dogs are short of human contact, and the authors suggested that need may speed bonding, so a family dog with a home and its own people may attach to a trainer more loosely. And the study shows a bond forming, not one being pushed aside. In practice a trainer your dog trusts is an asset during a stay, because a relaxed dog eats, rests and works without worry, and that is when it learns.

What the stay changes

A stay adds a working relationship; it does not move your dog's home base

What changes during a stay is narrow. Your dog learns to work with one more person, and its cues become tied to that person's voice, timing and posture, which is why it may answer the trainer faster at pick-up. What does not change is everything outside the training floor: months or years of shared history, your house, your car, your walking routes, the smell of your kitchen. A week or two adds a chapter to your dog's life; it does not rewrite the book.

Liking a trainer takes nothing away from you. A dog can look forward to a handler at work and still pull toward your car in the parking lot. The program is built on that assumption: it ends by moving every cue back into your hands, with one go-home lesson after the one-week Foundation program and two scheduled coaching lessons after the two-week Advanced. Our page on whether a dog forgets its family during a stay covers the attachment research in more depth.

  • Changes: your dog learns to work with another person
  • Changes: cues get tied to that person's voice and timing
  • Stays the same: your history, your home, your routines
  • Comes back to you: every cue, at the go-home lesson

The reunion

Pick-up day usually starts with a big greeting, sometimes for the trainer as well

Expect noise and wriggling when you walk in, and let it pass before anyone asks for a cue. Do not be surprised if your dog also greets its trainer warmly on the way out. That shows the stay was a good experience, not that loyalty is divided. Training method matters here: the 2021 AVSAB position statement says reward-based methods promote a strong, positive bond between dog and owner, while aversive methods damage the human-animal bond. Dogtown's training is fear- and force-free.

Pick-up happens in a window: weekdays 6:30 to 9:30 AM, 12 to 1 PM or 4 to 6:30 PM, and Saturdays 8 to 10 AM, 12 to 1 PM or 4 to 6 PM, with Sunday windows kept for overnight stays. Book a slot you can stay for, because the lesson follows the hello, and bring everyone who will walk or train the dog. If you would like your dog to come home clean, a bath before pick-up is $55 for a dog up to 25 pounds.

  • Let the greeting pass before any cue
  • Expect a warm goodbye to the trainer, too
  • Book a pick-up slot you can stay for
  • Bring everyone who will walk or train the dog

The first fortnight

For two weeks after the stay, be the person who runs the good parts of the day

Bonds are built from shared routine, so for the first fortnight put yourself in charge of the moments your dog values most. Serve every meal, with one cue from the lesson before the bowl goes down. Hold the leash on walks, on routes your dog already knows. Run the game it loves best, and do two short training sessions a day with the trainer's exact words and rewards. None of this is about competing with the trainer; it is about the cues meaning the same thing in your hands.

Hold back on handing the dog to new walkers or sitters for those two weeks if you can, and let other family members join in with the same cues. Later, a long-line recall at Good Harbor Beach on an even-numbered day between October 1 and March 31 makes a good test of how the partnership is going. If you want trainer time to continue, Dogtown Academy days are $89 full or $69 half, and the Pup Van collects from Rockport, Gloucester, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea for $10 each way.

  1. 01

    Meals: you serve them, with one cue before the bowl goes down

  2. 02

    Walks: you hold the leash, on familiar routes

  3. 03

    Play: you run the game your dog loves most

  4. 04

    Training: two short sessions a day, with the trainer's exact words

  5. 05

    Rest: a settle spot near the family, not shut away

  6. 06

    New walkers and visitors: after the routine has settled

At Dogtown

Keep the partnership going

Board and train hands the cues to you; Dogtown Academy days and the Pup Van keep trainer time going once your dog is home.

Every price on one page

Pick-up & drop-off

The Pup Van comes to you.

Pup Van pick-up and drop-off is available for $10 each way in the Rockport, Gloucester, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea area. Not in the area? Ask us for pricing.

  • Rockport
  • Gloucester
  • Essex
  • Manchester-by-the-Sea
The Dogtown Pup Van: a navy van with dog portraits, the Dogtown logo and the phone number on the side

Asked and answered

Questions people ask about this

Short, complete answers you can act on today. More in the full FAQ.

Will my dog be sad to leave the trainer?
Some dogs give their handlers an enthusiastic goodbye, which shows they enjoyed the stay. That does not mean they would rather remain. Once your dog is home, its meals, walks, bed and people are all yours again, and those are what its day is organized around.
Should I visit during the stay to protect the bond?
Whether visits fit the plan is confirmed at the consult, and for many dogs a mid-stay visit restarts the goodbye. A bond built over months or years of daily life is not worn away by a week or two apart. The daily updates keep you in touch with how your dog is doing in the meantime.
Why does my dog obey the trainer better than me at pick-up?
It has just spent one or two weeks practicing with that person's voice, timing and body language. That is practice, not preference, and the go-home lesson exists to transfer it. Our page on why dogs listen to the trainer and not their owner explains what to copy.
Is a rescue dog more likely to attach to the trainer?
A newly adopted rescue is still forming its bond with you, which is one reason a stay in the first weeks after adoption is usually a poor idea. Give it time at home to settle and attach. Calm & Connected, for adolescents, new rescues and adult dogs, keeps you working together from the first session.
Does a strong bond with the trainer mean better results?
It helps during the stay, because a dog that trusts its trainer eats, rests and works without worry. Results at home depend on the relationship with you and on daily practice, which is why every Dogtown program ends with you holding the leash rather than watching from the side.

More questions? Read the full FAQ

Sources

Rules and dates change. We re-check every beach, licensing and ordinance page each spring and fall; the source above is the current word.

Next step

Bring your dog home yours

Tell us who walks and trains your dog at home. We reply within one hour on business days and plan the handover around those people.

  1. 01Free evaluationWeekdays 6:30 – 9:30 AM
  2. 02Book a dayOnline, in the app or by phone
  3. 03Play, rest, repeatReport card at pick-up

Follow along

Daily photos and report cards.

Call Book now