- Home
- Board and train
- Is board and train cruel?
Welfare
Is board and train cruel?
The question is fair, and the honest answer is that the format is neutral and the details are not. Here is how to judge methods and housing, a five-part welfare check drawn from animal welfare science, and what Dogtown does.
The short version
Board and train is as humane as its methods and its housing
A board and train hands your dog to someone else, around the clock, for a week or two. That is the source of the worry and the reason the question deserves more than a yes or no. Under the same label, one program teaches with food, play and patience and keeps dogs in comfortable rooms with company, while another uses shock collars and leaves dogs crated between sessions. The format is identical; the dog's experience is not.
So judge the two things that decide it. Methods are what happens when your dog gets an answer wrong, which you will not see. Housing is everything else: where the dog sleeps, how long it is confined, whether it gets exercise, rest and company, and how its health is watched. A program that is open about both, in writing and before you pay, has less to hide than one that asks you to trust a results video.
- Methods: rewards, or pain and fear, when the dog gets it wrong
- Housing: where it sleeps and how long it is confined
- Daily life: exercise, rest, enrichment and company
- Openness: methods in writing and an update every day
Methods
Methods: the welfare test is what happens after a wrong answer
Professional bodies are clear about where the line sits. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior's 2021 position statement recommends only reward-based methods for all dog training, and tells trainers to avoid tools that work through pain, naming choke chains, prong collars and electronic shock collars, as well as intimidation and physical corrections such as leash jerking. The ASPCA's position on training aids says it opposes any equipment that causes a pet physical discomfort or undue anxiety.
Dogtown's training is fear- and force-free, built on positive reinforcement, mindfulness and clear communication. There are no e-collars, prong collars or choke chains in any program, and a dog that gets something wrong is given an easier next attempt rather than a correction. Gabriella Pope, our Director of Training & Canine Behaviorist, looks for the reason behind a behavior, whether fear, frustration or sensitivity, instead of trying to stamp it out.
- Ruled out by AVSAB's 2021 statement: choke chains, prong collars, shock collars
- Also ruled out: intimidation such as shouting, staring or alpha rolls
- Also ruled out: physical corrections such as leash jerking
- Used at Dogtown: markers, food, play and clear communication
Housing
Housing: the hours between lessons make up most of the stay
Training blocks fill a small part of any day; the rest is housing. Ask any program where dogs sleep, how long they spend confined, when they get out to move and rest, and who is there at night. At Dogtown in Gloucester, board and train dogs sleep in overnight suites under 24/7 monitoring, spend part of the day in a matched playgroup of 7 to 10 dogs once ready, and get enrichment between sessions. How night monitoring is staffed is a detail we confirm at the consult.
Regulation is still catching up. Massachusetts passed Ollie's Law, signed on September 20, 2024 and in effect from December 19, 2024, which directs the state's Department of Agricultural Resources to write rules for commercial boarding and training kennels. Those rules were due in 2026, and as of the advisory committee's March 18, 2026 minutes they had not been released. Until they are, the questions on this page are the best protection a family has.
A welfare check
A five-part welfare check you can run on any program, including ours
Animal welfare scientists assess an animal's life with the Five Domains Model, updated in 2020 by David Mellor and colleagues. Four domains, nutrition, physical environment, health and behavioral interactions, feed into the fifth, the animal's mental state. The 2020 version added interactions with people, listing training reinforcements and the companionable presence of people among the ways humans improve an animal's welfare, and unpleasant or threatening actions among the ways they damage it.
The table turns the model into questions for a board and train, with what a good answer sounds like and what Dogtown publishes today. Where we have not published something, the right-hand column says so. Ask every program the same five questions, compare the answers side by side, and treat a vague answer about methods or housing as an answer in itself.
| Domain | Ask any program | A good answer sounds like | What Dogtown publishes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nutrition | What will my dog eat, and when? | Your food, portioned, on your dog's schedule | Pre-portioned food from home |
| Physical environment | Where does my dog sleep and rest? | A clean, quiet space with monitoring at night | An overnight suite with 24/7 monitoring |
| Health | What is required, and who watches for illness? | Vaccines on file and a clear plan if a dog is unwell | Rabies, DHPP, Bordetella and a license; the rest at the consult |
| Behavioral interactions | How are other dogs, people and training handled? | Matched groups, choice and rewards | Groups of 7 to 10 when ready; force-free training |
| Mental state | How will I know how my dog is coping? | Specific daily reports on eating, sleep and mood | An update every day of the stay |
For your dog
For your dog, the honest risk is stress, so the right candidates matter
Even a humane stay asks something of a dog: a new building, new people and a new routine. Most dogs adjust, and a predictable day helps. Some should not board at all, including dogs that panic when confined, will not eat away from home or are in the middle of a fear period. A good program says so before you book, and our assessment exists partly to catch those dogs and point them to a program where you keep hold of the leash.
If you do book, you are not powerless during the stay. Read every daily update for eating, sleep and mood as well as skills, message the front desk the same day if something worries you, and watch your dog at the go-home lesson. A dog that works happily for food and leans toward its trainer has not been taught through fear, and you will see that in its body before you hear a word about its progress.
- 01
Before booking, get the methods and equipment in writing
- 02
Ask where your dog sleeps and how nights are monitored
- 03
Read the first updates for appetite, rest and mood
- 04
Message the front desk the same day if anything looks off
- 05
At the go-home lesson, watch how your dog responds to the trainer
At Dogtown
How a stay is run here
Force-free training, overnight suites with 24/7 monitoring and matched playgroups, all at 210 Eastern Ave in Gloucester.
Asked and answered
Questions people ask about this
Short, complete answers you can act on today. More in the full FAQ.
Is it cruel to send my dog away for two weeks?
Why do some trained dogs look so calm in program videos?
Is crating during a stay cruel?
Does Dogtown use any corrections or punishment?
What should I see at pick-up if the stay was humane?
More questions? Read the full FAQ
Sources
- Mellor et al. 2020: the Five Domains Model, in Animals (PMC)
- AVSAB: humane dog training position statement (2021)
- ASPCA: position statement on training aids and methods
- Mass.gov: Ollie's Law information
Rules and dates change. We re-check every beach, licensing and ordinance page each spring and fall; the source above is the current word.
Keep reading
Next step
Ask us the hard questions
Methods, sleep, nights and updates: put every question on this page to the training team before you book anything.
- 01Free evaluationWeekdays 6:30 – 9:30 AM
- 02Book a dayOnline, in the app or by phone
- 03Play, rest, repeatReport card at pick-up
